← /notes

Emergence

Created Dec 22, 2024 systemscomplexityreductionism

Water is wet. Hydrogen and oxygen are not wet. Wetness emerges from how the molecules interact. None of the parts have the property. The whole does.

This is emergence: properties that appear at the level of the system but don’t exist at the level of the components.


The examples stack up.

Neurons fire. Enough of them, connected in the right ways, and something happens that no individual neuron exhibits. Consciousness. The neural activity is measurable. The experience is undeniable. The connection between them remains a mystery.

Traders make individual decisions. The collective produces prices, trends, crashes — phenomena that exist only at the level of the market, not at the level of any participant.

Words have definitions. Combine them and meaning emerges that no word carries alone. Poetry, humor, irony. Properties of the arrangement.

Cities are buildings, roads, people. But a city is more than infrastructure plus population. It has character, pace, culture — things that dissolve when you try to locate them in any single element.


Emergence limits reductionism. Knowing everything about the parts doesn’t automatically tell you about the whole. The interactions generate novelty.

This matters for how you explain things. Traffic patterns require traffic vocabulary, even though cars are made of atoms. Consciousness requires mental vocabulary, even if it runs on neurons. The higher-level patterns are real. They need their own language.


I find this both frustrating and fascinating. You can understand every module in a codebase and still be surprised by how the system behaves. You can know every person in an organization and still not understand its culture.

The whole is what happens when parts interact. And interaction is where the interesting stuff lives.

Go Deeper

Books

  • Emergence by Steven Johnson — Accessible introduction via ants, cities, software.
  • Complexity: A Guided Tour by Melanie Mitchell — The best modern overview.

Related: systems, galls law, feedback loops, selection, scenius